Tallahassee, FL — In a significant blow to local governments seeking greater autonomy over land-use regulations, a Florida judge has dismissed four out of five counts in a lawsuit challenging SB 180, a law that restricts cities and counties from imposing certain growth controls. The ruling comes amid continued legislative efforts to address the contentious issue.
Background on SB 180
Signed into law by Governor Ron DeSantis in March 2023, SB 180 aims to streamline development and reduce regulatory hurdles for developers. However, it has faced significant pushback from local governments who argue that the law undermines their ability to manage growth effectively.
Judge's Ruling
In a decision handed down last week, Leon County Circuit Judge Terry Lewis ruled in favor of the state on four counts brought by the cities and counties challenging SB 180. The judge dismissed claims that the law violates the Florida Constitution’s home rule provision and that it unlawfully impinges on local government powers.
"The court found no basis for the plaintiffs' arguments, concluding that the law is within the state's authority to regulate land use," said a spokesperson for the Florida Attorney General's office.
Ongoing Legislative Efforts
The ruling comes as legislative efforts to amend or repeal SB 180 continue in Tallahassee. A bill introduced by Senator Jeff Brandes aimed at scaling back some of the law’s restrictions failed to gain traction during the recent legislative session.
"We are disappointed with the court's decision, but we will continue to work within the legislative process to ensure that local governments have the tools they need to manage growth effectively," said Mayor Alex Leitao of Orlando, one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
